Judge Orders Woman To Give Her Lingerie Photos To Her Ex-Husband In Their Divorce For “Memories Sake”

"For Memory's Sake"

Chris claims he wanted to keep the sensual album because he wanted to keep the loving messages she wrote to him along with the pictures. Never did Lindsay expect that the judge would approve Chris' request.

As a "compromise, " the Davis county judge ruled that Lindsay would give the albums to the original photographer to be edited, then give them to her ex-husband. He stated:

"That person is to do whatever it takes to modify the pages of the pictures so that any photographs of [Lindsay Marsh] in lingerie or that sort of thing or even without clothing are obscured and taken out," 2nd District Judge Michael Edwards wrote in the ruling via The Salt Lake Tribune.

But the words are maintained for memory's sake.”

The Photographer Refused

Lindsay felt like she had no choice but to obey the judge's ruling despite how violated it made her feel. Luckily the original photographer was a close friend of Lindsay's. Lindsay contacted them and explained the situation.

Her friend and photographer refused to edit the photos and gave two reasons for doing so: it was a violation of Lindsay's privacy, and it would also damage her business reputation and legitimacy as a boudoir photographer.

No Consideration Of Privacy And Consent

The judge could still not see Lindsay's and her photographer's perspectives even when the photographer refused. Instead, the judge ordered Lindsay to give the albums to a third party to edit them. The third party was a male graphic designer whom she had never met.

Lindsay couldn't wrap her head around the order. She remembers asking the judge's clerk's office: "I just want to clarify...The judge has ordered me to give nude photos of my body to a third party that I don’t know without my consent?”

Unfortunately, the answer to that question was yes and it made Lindsay quite distrusting of the law system. She explains: "You don't know where to turn because you don't know the law," adding. "And you have not only your ex-husband who you were married to for years … you have his attorney that also thinks that's OK. And then you bring it in front of a judge, and he thinks it's OK."

No Longer Applicable

Luckily when the original photographer heard of the new judge's ruling, they agreed to edit the photos after all. At least this way they were only seen by a photographer who Lindsay trusted ad was comfortable with seeing her body in such vulnerable poses.

The photographer took photos of the album's pages and edited large black boxes over any part of Lindsay's body, leaving behind the captions and comments that Lindsay had written for her husband.

If it were up to Lindsay she wouldn't even leave the message as they were no longer true and applicable. "That’s even violating," Lindsay thought, “because these are things that were sensual and loving that I wrote to my husband that I loved. You’re my ex-husband now.”

The Husband's Defense

As for the ex-husband, Chris stands by the ruling and does not find it problematic to have made this request. The Digital copies of these photos were printed out, stapled together, and handed over to him. He seems to think that these albums are not "inappropriate-type books" and the photos weren't as “intimate” as Lindsay has led people to believe.

“I cherish the loving memories we had for all those years as part of normal and appropriate exchanges between a husband and wife,” he told The Salt Lake Tribune, “and sought to preserve that in having the inscriptions.” To Chris, this album is representative of the good times they once shared that he's still holding onto.

Exposing The Events

Lindsay doesn't mean to attack her husband but she has shared her stories in hopes of exposing the judge's decision on accounting of it being "violating and it’s incredibly embarrassing and humiliating."

She hopes that by doing so, she can prevent the next woman from feeling the same way: “The only way I can hopefully protect someone else from going through the same situation is to tell my story and expose that these are the types of things that he thinks are OK.”

Lindsay is required to keep her albums for 90 days after the ruling but then she plans on having a burning party and throwing them into the fire to get rid of them forever.

Pick Your Husbands Carefully

Before you take the leap in committing to someone forever, always look at how you feel and ask yourself: does this person make you love yourself more? Do you want to grow old with them?

Love is more than just kisses and butterflies, it's much more than that. If you want to know more about what your birth chart reveals about how you love and what you need out of a partner, check out this personalized report based on your date of birth.

For more great relationship advice and tips on how to attain the kind of love you deserve, watch this video from expert, Amy North: Click Here To Watch The Full Video.